The Mingary Castle restoration blog was written by Jon Haylett, who lives in the local village of Kilchoan. Now that restoration is almost complete Holly and Chris Bull will take over to report on bringing the Castle back to life.
Showing posts with label Engineering. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Engineering. Show all posts

Wednesday, 30 December 2015

Sea Wall Drawings

When the site closed for the Christmas and New Year holidays work was progressing as well as could be expected on the sea wall which is being built to stabilise the lower part of the cliff face on which the castle stands. The first part of this process was to erect shuttering in stages along with appropriate reinforcing, and then to pour concrete to form the core of the wall.

Brian Smith, Technical Director at Arc Engineers, who is the structural engineer for Mingary Castle, has kindly made available his latest sketch details for the wall.

The first one shows the point at which the work currently stands, with the upper blocks of granophyre having been pinned some two years ago, and most of the concrete now poured to form the core of the sea wall.

Once the concrete has set, the next stage is to face the wall with local stone so that it blends in to the surrounding rock. Sourcing appropriate rock and moving it into place will be one of the challenges facing the builders and, once again, progress will be heavily dependent on the tides and on the weather, which isn't at its kindest in January and February.

Thursday, 30 April 2015

Stabilising the Dolerite

Architect Francis Shaw of Shaw & Jagger and the project's structural engineer Brian Smith of Arc Engineers were on site yesterday morning to look at the last remaining major engineering problem of this work - what to do about the dolerite layer which lies below the granophyre.  This picture was taken back in 2010, before any work began.

Readers will recall that the granophyre was stabilised in a spectacular way back in May 2013 by inserting steel rods which pinned back the falling blocks of rock, an operation which saved the castle's curtain walls from tumbling into the sea.

Even though it showed signs of erosion by the pounding of seven centuries of storm waves, the dolerite wasn't fixed at the same time because it is exceptionally hard, and was quite strong enough to bear the additional weight of the scaffolding.  But, now that the scaffolding is close to being removed, decisions have to be made about stabilising the dolerite.

Francis, right, and Brian, pointing, spent some time with builders Mark Rutherford Thompson (to Brian's left) and John-Paul Ashley (left) looking at the problem.

Not only does Brian have to come up with a way of stabilising the rock, he is also determined that any 'fix' will last a good few hundred years.

While decisions have yet to be made, the outline of Brian's ideas is shown in this sketch. The bulk of the 'fix' is concrete, held in against the dolerite using two metre 'rock nails'.  Outside this concrete is a further layer of corrosion-resistant concrete to which a facing of local rocks will be held using high-grade stainless steel brackets through which a reinforcing wire mesh will be threaded.

It's little wonder that Mark looks worried in this picture as it will be J-P and he that are doing the work.  But it's the sort of challenge they seem to relish, though there's one other problem the builders to contend with - the tide comes in twice a day and covers this area.

Thursday, 4 December 2014

Stabilising the Curtain Walls

The last time we saw Alasdair Smith (right) and Liam Martin of UKdima Engineering Ltd at the castle, they were drilling two large holes through the basement rock from the moat into the castle to carry the services, including the heating from the biofuel boiler.  They've been down again over the last few weeks, this time drilling much smaller holes through the bases of the curtain walls as part of a process of stabilising the walls.

The method is very similar to that used to pin the huge granophyre blocks in place when work first started on the castle, with forty-two steel reinforcing pins being inserted through the bottoms of the walls, from the outside into the courtyard, epoxied into place, and then plates placed on either end and screwed tight to pull the two sides together.

This plan shows a vertical view through one of the curtain walls. Blocks had to be removed from the exterior (left)....

....and the hole drilled through the base of the wall.

The steel rods were then inserted, and steel plates screwed tight on either end.

Later, the rocks that had been removed were replaced and mortared into position so the plate is hidden.  The mortar here has yet to be brushed, so it will quickly blend in with the rest.

When I went down to the castle today, a small team, including Richard (pictured), was working on the base of the walls, the one place where the pointing hasn't been completed.  Until recently, the scaffolding wasn't in place to make it accessible.

The lowest section of the west wall is now almost complete, but they have to work their way round all the other walls.  Here's hoping that the weather holds so that this, one of the last jobs that have to be done on the exterior walls, can be completed as soon as possible.  Then, some time after New Year, the scaffolding will come down and the refurbished and strengthened walls will be revealed.

Picture of steel plate courtesy Mark Thompson.

Thursday, 15 May 2014

Diamond Drilling

There's a lot happening on site at the moment.  The blockwork is finished on the biomass boiler house so it's ready for the horizontal steel supports that will hold up the roof.  The landward end is being backfilled ready for this.  Damien Summerscales, who is putting in the strengthening rods - see last week's post - has nearly finished, and the architect is due down this weekend, so hopefully work can start shortly on the roof of the main, north block.

The main interest today was a team from UKdima Engineering Ltd, site drilling specialists, of Stirling, who were there to drill two 450mm diameter holes through the base of the castle wall into the room which gave access to the well.  The holes angle up at 15 degrees.  One will take the biomass boiler extract, which will go up one of the castle chimneys, the other will carry the water and drainage pipes.  The heating system will access the castle through the well itself.

The men on site today were Alasdair Smith, right, and Liam Martin, who were kind enough to show me how their machine worked.

The drill holes are passing up through a blockwork buttress which was built last week.  The bit works very much on the same principle as the attachments I have for my hand drill which I use for making large holes in wood.  The rotating drill bit - blue - has to be forced against the rock wall, and this is done by turning a handle which connects a cog to the ratcheted steel rail that angles up beneath the bit, this rail being bolted to the blockwork.

The two black pipes are attached to a hydraulic unit, from which fluid is pumped to turn the drill bit. The yellow pipe is for water to cool the 'sharp' end of the bit.

As with oil-drilling bits, the teeth here are tipped with diamonds, which....

....can be seen in close-up here.  How long they last depends on the hardness of the rock.

Alasdair and Liam arrived on site yesterday and hope to be away by the weekend, though much depends on how resistant the rocks of the castle wall prove to be.

Many thanks to Liam and Alasdair for their patience in explaining their work.

Monday, 3 June 2013

Rock Stars

We were at the start of a beautiful Ardnamurchan day when I arrived at the castle site this morning, hardly a breath of wind, the sea a flat calm, and the clouds clearing to give a still, sunny day - all completely out of keeping with the bustling activity around the castle.  Work has now started on the main excavation at the eastern end of the moat.  A small digger is being used to scrape off a few centimetres of earth at a time.  The rubble is about two metres deep, so they'll work this way for the first 75 centimetres or so, after which the archaeologists will be down on their hands and knees with their trowels.

Even now, working through the relatively young rubble, the archaeologists are in constant attendance as each layer is removed - that's Ross from Addyman Archaeology in the blue safety helmet doing his 'real archaeology', while, doing all the delicate earth removal work, there's Howard working the digger and John-Paul of Ashley Thompson, very much a 'hands on' even though he's the main contractor for all building works, driving the dumper.

Inside the castle, excavations has started inside the north range.  This picture shows the main room with archaeologist Dave Henderson working his way down through the debris of centuries.  Look beyond him into the corner and the slates that were once on the roof can be seen, so he's digging at a layer that probably formed when they fell down, shortly after 1848 when the building was abandoned.

Just to Dave's left, built in to the main north curtain wall, is a carefully shaped rectangular piece of rock - look to the left and up from the bucket.  It looks like the flat face of a flagstone.  It doesn't look much, but to me it's part of the fascination of this excavation: that beautifully dressed slab of rock may have been placed there in the late 13th century, or later.  Why?

Phil, one of the workers with Ashley Thompson, is working to clear the upper layers under one of the windows.  In the last few days the more fragile of the entrances and windows have been carefully boxed in with wood to protect them - the sill above his head is an example.

While all this frenetic activity was going on in and around the castle, the danger men from Vertical Technology were.... fishing; or, at least, Tony was, while his three mates were having a cup of tea.  And one can understand why these breaks are necessary, as....

....the work, once it starts, is punishing, and they have to take breaks to prevent injury. Despite this, progress has been spectacular: of the 80 - 85 holes that have to be drilled, they've completed about 40.

The danger these men face every day was vividly brought home when....

....this large slab of rock fell from the cliff while they were drilling through it.  Fortunately, it moved and then stopped so, while it teetered on the edge of falling, John-Paul helped them to shore it up until they could carry out a controlled collapse.  Little wonder there's a television programme in the USA which features men doing this job, called Rock Stars.

This is the end result, with a plate bolted against the end of the steel rod and screwed tight, pulling the loose rock slab back into position.

That whole slabs are falling away shows how precarious the castle foundation has become, and how urgent the work of stabilising it.

Thursday, 30 May 2013

Saving Mingary from Collapse - 2

When I visited the site on Tuesday the team from Vertical Technology had completed the 'easy' bit in the moat and were living up to the company's name, hanging off the very vertical cliff below the west curtain wall while drilling into the hard granophyre.  Each of the two men working on the face - John in the yellow helmet and Tony in the blue - are attached to the top of the cliff by two ropes, the main and the safety.  The two ropes running right up the cliff, which go over the battlements and are fixed in the castle courtyard, carry the weight of the drill.

The drill is driven by compressed air and was developed for use in mining.  The two men operating it have to exert considerable pressure on it to work it into the cliff, and it's juddering and leaping around all the time.  They work a maximum of half-an-hour before taking a break.

As team leader, it's Simon's job to act as safety officer, checking things like the ropes, the knots, and that the men are working safely - not, for example, immediately under a large lump of rock that's about to fall off.

In all they have some 80 - 85 holes to sink into the granophyre, the exact location and depth of each calculated by Francis Shaw of Wighton Jagger Shaw and marked on photographs of the cliff faces.  Weather permitting - what is most likely to delay them is high winds - this should take three to four weeks.

Finally, here's another picture of this cheerful team - which includes, at bottom right, the real team leader.

Many thanks to Simon, Tony, John and Roger for the warm welcome I received while watching them work, and to Simon for his patience in explaining what was going on.

Tuesday, 28 May 2013

Saving Mingary from Collapse - 1

The great curtain walls of Mingary Castle are on the point of collapsing because the rock on which they are built, a very hard granophyre, is breaking into blocks which are falling apart - see earlier blog entry here.  To stop this happening - and it might happen at any moment - the blocks have to be pinned back in place, and to do that the Mingary Castle Preservation & Restoration Trust have called in some experts.


Vertical Technology is a Portsmouth-based company which specialises in, as they put it, "undertaking works complicated by height and difficult access."  This includes a wide variety of jobs from painting bridges to pinning back rock that might fall onto a road, from cleaning stonework on the faces of high city buildings to inspecting inaccessible structures such as steel bridges, and dealing with crumbling castles - they've worked on Lulworth and Old Sarum in the past.

The team which has come to Mingary are, from left, Roger Picolo who comes from Andorra, John Willis who used to instal solar panels, Tony Cottrell, an ex-fireman, and team leader Simon Scales, an ex-salesman of surf-boards.  They may have come from a variety of backgrounds, but all have considerable experience with Vertical Technology and are trained to the International Rope Access Trade Association's very high standards - Simon, as team leader, has been with VT for five years and is IRATA Level 3.

They start by removing a core about 4" in diameter and 6" deep.  They then drill a 35mm or 45mm hole  to a depth of 2m, 3m or 4m until they reach solid rock deep under the castle.  Either resin or grout is then injected, and a threaded stainless steel rod inserted before the resin/grout sets.  Once it has hardened, a 4" 'washer' is slipped over the protruding end of the steel rod, and a nut screwed onto it, heaving the rock back into place.  Finally, the 4" core is fitted back into the hole, concealing the top of the rod.

When they first started work last week, the main problems they contended with were the juddering of the drill and the deafening noise, but then they were only experimenting at an easily accessible location - the castle moat - to see what the rock was like.  But when I went down today to see how they were getting on, the team was working under the west wall, and that was.... impressive.

To be continued....